
India vs China thorium reactors is usually told as a race: China sprinting, India stalling.
On 1 November 2025, the Shanghai Institute of Applied Physics announced that a small experimental reactor in Wuwei, in China’s Gansu province, had converted thorium into uranium fuel while operating, a first for a molten salt reactor. Five months later, on 6 April 2026, India’s 500-megawatt Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor at Kalpakkam in Tamil Nadu reached criticality after more than two decades of construction and delay.
Read side by side, the two announcements seem to confirm that story. The record is more complicated. The two countries are not running the same race. They are at different points on very different routes to thorium, and neither has built a thorium power plant that sells electricity.
This investigation sets out what each country has demonstrated, what it has only announced, and what remains unresolved. It starts with a 1954 plan that explains why India’s road to thorium is so long.
What Is Thorium, and Why Does It Matter for India and China?
Thorium is a weakly radioactive metal, about three times more abundant than uranium, that can be turned into fissile uranium-233 inside a reactor. It cannot sustain a chain reaction on its own, so it needs a starter fuel. Thorium in plain terms: promising, but not magic
Thorium-232 cannot sustain a chain reaction on its own. It is “fertile”: when it absorbs a neutron it becomes uranium-233, which is fissile. A thorium reactor therefore always needs a starter fuel, usually plutonium-239 or enriched uranium, to get the process going, as the World Nuclear Association points out. The International Atomic Energy Agency describes thorium as roughly three times more abundant in the Earth’s crust than uranium.
For India, the case is fuel security. The country holds only around 1 to 2 per cent of the world’s uranium but has the largest thorium resources in the USGS’s latest estimate, and its reactors depend heavily on imported uranium. Thorium is the one large nuclear fuel India has at home, which is why Bhabha built the whole programme around it.
For China, the stated logic is as much industrial as it is about fuel. The Shanghai Institute of Applied Physics says thorium suits the country because it occurs alongside rare earths, which China produces in large quantities. It also points to pairing the reactors with wind and solar power and with high-temperature heat for hydrogen and chemicals, and it chose Wuwei in Gansu partly for that reason. The programme is also framed as building a domestically controlled supply chain: the institute reports that key core equipment is made entirely in China.
In both countries the case for thorium is strategic rather than economic, and the technical problems below explain why.
Two technical facts explain both the enthusiasm and the delay. First, uranium-233 is contaminated with uranium-232, whose decay products emit hard gamma radiation. That makes the fuel less attractive for weapons, but it also forces remote handling at every stage of reprocessing. Second, breeding fuel from thorium has so far not been cost-effective while uranium remains cheap.
That is why popular claims that thorium is “waste-free” or “proliferation-proof” deserve caution. Breeder cycles bring their own safeguards questions, and the engineering is harder than the slogans suggest.
The 1954 plan: Bhabha’s long relay
In November 1954, at a conference on atomic energy for peaceful purposes, Homi Bhabha presented the blueprint that became India’s three-stage nuclear programme. The government formally adopted it in 1958.
His arithmetic was simple. India’s thorium resources exceeded 500,000 tons, while its known uranium reserves were less than a tenth of that. The long-range aim, he argued, should be to base nuclear power “on thorium rather than uranium” as soon as possible, using the first generation of natural-uranium stations only to start the programme and to produce the plutonium needed to convert thorium into uranium-233.
The three stages follow from that logic:
- Stage one: pressurised heavy water reactors burning natural uranium. India judged heavy water easier to produce than enriched uranium.
- Stage two: fast breeder reactors that burn plutonium and breed more fissile material, including uranium-233 from thorium blankets.
- Stage three: advanced reactors designed around thorium and uranium-233.
What the popular version of the story leaves out is that the plan was never thorium-first. It is thorium-last by design, a relay in which every earlier leg has to be completed at scale before the baton can pass. That is the essential difference from China’s approach, and it is why “India is sitting on a goldmine” understates the engineering sequence. The mine cannot be worked until the stage-two infrastructure exists.
Evidence that the relay has moved, slowly
India’s Fast Breeder Test Reactor, a 40-megawatt thermal design, began operating in 1985 at the Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research. In the 1990s the small KAMINI research reactor at Kalpakkam began running on uranium-233. Indian heavy water power reactors have also used thorium oxide bundles in their initial cores, according to government replies in Parliament.
But the timetable has always been long. In a Lok Sabha reply from the period of the 12th Five-Year Plan (2012–2017), the government said the third stage would be launched only three to four decades after adequate fast breeder capacity had been built. India’s thorium plan was a multi-generation commitment from the start, not a program that recently fell asleep.


India’s thorium journey was not built on vague optimism but on firm scientific reasoning and strategic foresight. Here are documented views from the three greatest minds behind India’s nuclear program:
Statements from India’s Nuclear Pioneers
Subsequent scientists like Dr. Vikram Sarabhai and Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam upheld this vision. Kalam, in his book Target 3 Billion, emphasized thorium’s potential to deliver clean and indigenous energy, particularly for rural electrification.
Dr. Homi Jehangir Bhabha (1954)
“The total reserves of thorium in India amount to over 500,000 tons … The aim of a long‑range atomic power programme in India must … be to base the nuclear power generation as soon as possible on thorium rather than uranium… The first generation of atomic power stations based on natural uranium … can only be used to start an atomic power programme. The plutonium produced … can be used … to convert thorium into U‑233 …”
In a 1954 address at the Conference on the Development of Atomic Energy for Peaceful Purposes, Bhabha stated:
“The aim of a long-range atomic power programme in India must be to base the nuclear power generation as soon as possible on thorium rather than uranium.”
Bhabha not only recognized thorium’s abundance but also engineered the Three-Stage Nuclear Programme specifically to convert it into usable energy via plutonium and U‑233.
Dr. Vikram Sarabhai
While better known for his space achievements, Sarabhai supported Bhabha’s thorium-driven approach, advocating for peaceful and Indigenous nuclear development:
“We must develop nuclear energy for peaceful purposes. It is essential to our progress that India becomes self-reliant in this critical technology.”
Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam
In Target 3 Billion and numerous speeches, Kalam repeatedly called for India to leverage thorium for rural energy independence:
“India has to develop the thorium-based reactor technology to meet the future power demand and achieve energy independence. It is not just a scientific goal; it is a national mission.”
Kalam also endorsed and promoted the AHWR design, calling it essential to India’s long-term energy security and self-reliance.
Achievements and Stagnation
India’s Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) and Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC) pursued thorium-related research:

- In 1996, India commissioned the Kamini reactor at Kalpakkam; the world’s only functioning reactor using U‑233 derived from thorium. However, it was limited to experimental and isotope production purposes.
- The Advanced Heavy Water Reactor (AHWR) was designed as a thorium prototype using U‑233 and LEU (low-enriched uranium) to produce 300 MW of electricity. Its development began in the early 2000s, but commercial deployment remains elusive even in 2025.
India’s progress has been largely confined to the research phase. While thorium is regularly cited in government energy reports and scientific papers, the absence of pilot or commercial-scale thorium reactors reflects a deep policy and execution vacuum.
As former Chairman of the Atomic Energy Commission, Dr. Anil Kakodkar, pointed out in a 2010 interview:
“Thorium is our strategic asset. But due to international dynamics and constraints, our attention has been diverted from its timely exploitation.”
India’s thorium programme: milestones and open problems
The breeder finally reaches criticality
The Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor attained first criticality on 6 April 2026. Construction began in 2004, and the American Nuclear Society’s Nuclear News describes the milestone as more than 15 years behind schedule, citing supply-chain problems, regulatory requirements and delays at the associated fuel cycle facility. The reactor uses uranium-plutonium mixed oxide fuel surrounded by a uranium-238 blanket, but its design also allows the blanket to hold thorium-232, which would be converted into uranium-233.
Two cautions apply. Criticality is the start of a sustained chain reaction, not delivery of power to the grid, and the Department of Atomic Energy had not announced when the reactor would enter operation. It is also not India’s first breeder, since it builds on the 1985 test reactor.
The thorium reactor that exists only on paper
Stage three centres on the 300-megawatt Advanced Heavy Water Reactor (AHWR), designed by the Bhabha Atomic Research Centre as a technology demonstrator for thorium use. The government gave in-principle approval to a site at Tarapur in December 2016. A critical test facility has existed at BARC since 2008. Yet a Business Today analysis in April 2026 noted that, ten years after the site approval, the AHWR remained in the research and development phase.
The AHWR has not been decommissioned, as it is sometimes described. It has simply not been built.
A legal reset
India’s nuclear law has also changed. The SHANTI Act of 2025 replaced the Atomic Energy Act of 1962 and the Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act of 2010, and it allows private companies to apply for licences to build, own and operate nuclear plants and to fabricate fuel, under regulatory oversight. Industry commentators quoted after the PFBR milestone said suppliers’ liability worries had been addressed but that commercial viability, including cost, still had to be proved.
The scale problem
India’s nuclear sector is still small relative to its needs. Analysis citing government data puts installed nuclear capacity at about 8.78 gigawatts in February 2026, producing 3.79 per cent of the country’s electricity. The American Nuclear Society calculates that India operates about 6 megawatts of nuclear capacity per million people, against roughly 285 for the United States and 921 for France. Thorium is a long-term answer to a fuel-security problem. The nearer-term problem is that India needs far more nuclear capacity of every kind.
China’s thorium programme: what has been demonstrated
An American idea, state-backed
In January 2011 the Chinese Academy of Sciences launched a research programme on thorium-breeding molten salt reactors. World Nuclear News reported it as a CNY 3 billion (about US$444 million) effort and the world’s largest national programme of its kind. The liquid-fuel design descends from the Molten-Salt Reactor Experiment at Oak Ridge National Laboratory in the United States, which went critical in 1965 and in October 1968 became the first reactor to run on uranium-233. The American breeder project was later discontinued. China picked up the abandoned line of research.
The Wuwei reactor, step by step
The experimental TMSR-LF1 is a 2-megawatt thermal reactor. The key dates, as reported by World Nuclear News and POWER magazine:
- September 2018: construction begins.
- August 2022: the Ministry of Ecology and Environment approves commissioning.
- June 2023: operating licence granted.
- 11 October 2023: first criticality.
- June 2024: full operation.
- October 2024: thorium added to the molten salt, which the institute calls a world first.
- 1 November 2025: announcement of thorium-to-uranium conversion.
Because the fuel is dissolved in the salt, the design allows refuelling without shutting the reactor down. The institute reports that over 90 per cent of the reactor’s components are made in China, and that nearly 100 institutions, universities and companies took part in the project.
How big a result is it?
The result is real and important, and it is also small. The Chinese Academy of Sciences calls the reactor the only operational molten salt reactor in the world loaded with thorium fuel. But according to World Nuclear News, the design uses only about 50 kilograms of thorium, with a conversion ratio of about 0.1. A conversion ratio well below one means the reactor creates far less new fissile material than it consumes. It is a research platform for studying the thorium cycle, not a breeder, and not a power plant. POWER magazine adds that the institute had not released detailed technical data on the conversion process.
Every claim about the reactor’s performance so far comes from the institute that built it. That is normal for a new research reactor, but it is worth stating plainly.
The roadmap
The stated next steps are a 10-megawatt demonstration reactor by 2029 and a 100-megawatt-class demonstration by 2035, aimed at thorium-rich regions such as Gansu and Xinjiang. Earlier reporting, from 2022, mentioned a 373-megawatt thermal reactor by 2030. Current official language points to the more modest 100-megawatt thermal target for 2035, a reminder that roadmaps in this field change.
Reserves: India’s real advantage, and what the numbers say

The U.S. Geological Survey’s 2026 Mineral Commodity Summaries estimates identified world thorium resources at about 6.4 million tons. India has the largest share at 850,000 tons, followed by Brazil at 630,000 and Australia and the United States at 600,000 each. India’s share is therefore roughly 13 per cent of the world total, well below the 25 to 30 per cent often repeated in popular coverage.
Two further points matter. These are resources, not proven economically recoverable reserves, and thorium is currently recovered only as a by-product of monazite sands mined for rare earths. And China does not appear among the USGS’s leading holders. Some Chinese-sourced estimates cited in media put its thorium at 1.3 to 1.4 million tons, but those figures are unaudited. The Chinese institute itself ties the programme to China’s large rare-earth industry. Treat claims about Chinese reserves as unverified.
India vs China Thorium Programmes: Side-by-Side Comparison
| India | China | |
|---|---|---|
| Thorium resources (USGS, latest) | Largest: about 850,000 t | Not among USGS’s leading holders; larger Chinese-sourced claims unverified |
| Thorium in an operating reactor | KAMINI (U-233, research scale); thoria bundles in heavy water reactor cores | TMSR-LF1, 2 MWt, thorium loaded Oct 2024 |
| Thorium-to-uranium conversion shown in operation | Planned via breeder stage | Announced Nov 2025 (institute’s own data) |
| Next major step | PFBR to enter operation; AHWR not yet built | 10 MW demonstration targeted for 2029 |
| Commercial scale | Decades away, on current official plans | 100 MWt demonstration targeted for 2035 |
So who is actually ahead?
It depends on which leg of the race you measure.
China leads on molten salt experience with thorium in a running reactor, and on the speed of iteration that a single state-backed programme can achieve. It went from construction in 2018 to thorium conversion in 2025.
India leads on resource base, on decades of thorium fuel handling, on a much larger operating nuclear fleet and, since April 2026, on having a large fast breeder in the stage-two position that its plan requires. But it has no thorium reactor under construction, and its own timeline for stage three is measured in decades.
Neither has demonstrated thorium electricity at commercial scale or the economics to support it. Private ventures abroad, such as Denmark’s Copenhagen Atomics, claim first commercial deployment of thorium molten salt reactors by 2030, but those are company targets, not demonstrated results.
The honest answer is that China is ahead on thorium in molten salt reactors, India is ahead on the long industrial chain that its own plan depends on, and “who wins” will be decided by what each does in the next ten years rather than by what either has announced.
What neither country has solved
Several problems cut across both programmes:
- Protactinium-233. This intermediate product in making uranium-233 is a major neutron absorber, which complicates breeding.
- Materials. Molten fluoride salts are corrosive, and some designs rely on expensive nickel alloys that can become brittle under intense neutron radiation.
- Fuel handling. Uranium-233’s gamma radiation demands remote handling and shielding in fuel fabrication and reprocessing.
- Economics. Uranium is cheap, and thorium breeding must eventually compete with it.
Molten salt reactors do operate at low pressure, which reduces some accident risks, but low pressure does not make a reactor risk-free.
What to watch next
- When the Department of Atomic Energy announces the PFBR’s entry into power operation.
- Whether the AHWR moves from design to a construction decision.
- The first private licence applications under the SHANTI Act.
- Whether China’s 10-megawatt demonstration reactor stays on its 2029 schedule.
- Independent technical data on the Wuwei conversion results.
Conclusion
Bhabha’s 1954 bet was that India could use its modest uranium to unlock its large thorium. Seven decades on, that bet has reached its second stage, late and at great cost, but it has reached it. China, starting from an American experiment that was shelved, has built the first reactor to show thorium being converted to uranium in a running molten salt reactor, though at a scale of two megawatts.
The common framing, a sleeping giant and a sprinting rival, fits neither country’s record. India has been methodical and slow. China has been fast and, so far, small. The more useful question for the next decade is not who announces the next milestone, but who first turns thorium into reliable, affordable electricity.
Also Read:
- Homi Bhabha’s Death: An Unfortunate Accident or the Hands of the Crow.
- The Strange Disappearance of India’s Nuclear Scientists.
Stay Updated: Follow our WhatsApp Channel and Telegram Channel.
Sources and references
- Parikh, Harsh. “Thorium in India.“
- “Details of Thorium Reserves,” Government of India, Department of Atomic Energy, 10 May 12.
- “Energy Statistics India – 2023,” National Statistical Office, Government of India, March 2023.
- N. K. Deb, “Nuclear Power – A Future Realistic,” in 75 Years of Indian Independence: The Changing Landscape, edited by D. Das (B. D. Prakash, 2023).
- Parekh, Shiv. “India’s Three-Stage Nuclear Program.“
- Availability of Thorium, Press Information Bureau, Government of India, 10 August 2011
- Rahman, Maseeh (1 November 2011a), “How Homi Bhabha’s vision turned India into a nuclear R&D leader”, The Guardian
- Bhabha, Homi J. Development of Atomic Energy for Peaceful Purposes in India. Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India, 1958.
- Bhabha, Homi J. Collected Scientific Papers. Indian National Science Academy, 1985.
- Sarabhai, Vikram. Collected Works of Vikram Sarabhai. Vol. 2, edited by C. Ramachandra Rao, Indian Space Research Organisation, 2000.
- Subramanian, T. S. “Vikram Sarabhai: A Life.” Frontline, The Hindu Group, 2001.
- Kalam, A. P. J., and Srijan Pal Singh. Target 3 Billion: PURA; Innovative Solutions Towards Sustainable Development. Penguin Books, 2011.
- Kalam, A. P. J. Ignited Minds: Unleashing the Power Within India. Penguin Books India, 2002.
- Kalam, A. P. J. “Inaugural Address at the International Conference on Energy, 2003,” APJ Abdul Kalam Foundation.
- Karnad, Bharat. India’s Nuclear Policy. Praeger Security International, 2008.
- Ramana, M. V. The Power of Promise: Examining Nuclear Energy in India. Penguin Books, 2012.
- Bhabha Atomic Research Centre – Thorium and AHWR Research
- Department of Atomic Energy – India’s Three-Stage Nuclear Programme
- Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research – Kamini & Breeder Reactor Info
- Atomic Minerals Directorate – Thorium Reserve Maps and Monazite Data
- International Atomic Energy Agency – Thorium Fuel Cycle Report
- World Nuclear Association – Thorium
- U.S. Geological Survey – Thorium in Mineral Commodity Summaries
- China Fires Up First Next-Generation Nuclear Reactor – Bloomberg
- China’s Thorium Bet – MIT Technology Review
- Dr. Anil Kakodkar on the Thorium Path – The Hindu
- Why Thorium is Still Not Powering India – The Indian Express
- What Happened to India’s Thorium Plans – Times of India
- Flibe Energy – Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor (LFTR)
- Oak Ridge National Laboratory – Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE)
- Chinese Academy of Sciences – Thorium MSR Program
- Moltex Energy – Thorium MSR and Stable Salt Reactor
India: reactors, plan and policy
- Press Information Bureau, factsheet on PFBR first criticality (April 2026): https://www.pib.gov.in/FactsheetDetails.aspx?id=150617
- American Nuclear Society, “India’s PFBR attains criticality at last” (14 April 2026): https://www.ans.org/news/2026-04-14/article-7936/indias-pfbr-attains-criticality-at-last/
- Down To Earth, “One step closer”: https://www.downtoearth.org.in/energy/one-step-closer
- Observer Research Foundation, “India’s PFBR Achieves Criticality”: https://www.orfonline.org/expert-speak/india-s-pfbr-achieves-criticality-implications-for-india-s-nuclear-future
- ThePrint/PTI, experts on the Kalpakkam reactor: https://theprint.in/india/landmark-step-but-concerns-remain-experts-on-kalpakkam-nuclear-reactor-reaching-criticality/2898885
- PIB, SHANTI Act 2025 and nuclear mission document: https://static.pib.gov.in/WriteReadData/specificdocs/documents/2026/apr/doc202647841801.pdf
- Drishti IAS, SHANTI Act and PFBR analysis: https://www.drishtiias.com/pdf/1781078757.pdf
- HDFC Mutual Fund, nuclear programme analysis (capacity and share of generation): https://www.hdfcfund.com/learn/deep-dives/tuesday-talking-point/india-steps-stage-2-its-nuclear-power-programme-defining-moment-energy-security
- PIB, AHWR site approval at Tarapur: https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1496193
- Rajya Sabha reply on AHWR status (2023): https://rsdebate.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/739938/1/PQ_259_09022023_U805_p114_p115.pdf
- Business Today, “Why thorium-based reactors are decades away from deployment” (April 2026): https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/economy/story/bt-explainer-why-thorium-based-reactors-are-decades-away-from-deployment-525258-2026-04-12
- BARC, Advanced Heavy Water Reactor: https://barc.gov.in/randd/ahwr.html
- Lok Sabha reply on thoria bundles in PHWR cores: https://eparlib.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/686348/1/395.pdf
- Lok Sabha reply on the timing of the third stage: https://eparlib.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/632387/1/132649.pdf
- Overview of India’s three-stage programme, including the 1954 Bhabha statement (secondary source; check against the primary 1954 text): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/India%27s_three-stage_nuclear_power_programme
China: thorium molten salt reactor
- World Nuclear News, “Chinese molten salt reactor achieves conversion of thorium-uranium fuel”: https://world-nuclear-news.org/articles/chinese-msr-achieves-conversion-of-thorium-uranium-fuel
- World Nuclear News, “Chinese molten-salt reactor cleared for start up” (2022): https://world-nuclear-news.org/articles/chinese-molten-salt-reactor-cleared-for-start-up
- POWER magazine, “China’s Molten Salt Reactor Reaches Thorium-Uranium Conversion Milestone”: https://www.powermag.com/chinas-molten-salt-reactor-reaches-thorium-uranium-conversion-milestone/
- Chinese Academy of Sciences newsroom (4 November 2025): https://english.cas.cn/newsroom/cas_media/202511/t20251104_1095922.shtml
- China Daily, thorium-to-uranium conversion report (1 November 2025): https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202511/01/WS6905af81a310f215074b86a8_5.html
- Nuclear Engineering International coverage of the TMSR result: https://www.neimagazine.com/?p=99830
Background and reserves
- U.S. Geological Survey, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026, Thorium: https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-thorium.pdf
- World Nuclear Association, Molten Salt Reactors: https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-and-future-generation/molten-salt-reactors
- Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Molten Salt Reactor Experiment history: https://ornl.gov/molten-salt-reactor/history
FACT CHECK: We strive for accuracy and fairness. But if you see something that doesn’t look right, please Contact us.
DISCLOSURE: This Article may contain affiliate links and Sponsored ads, to know more please read our Privacy Policy.










